Blog

"The opinions expressed in this blog are those of the authors, and do not necessarily represent the position of The American Fertility Association."


The Social Implications of a Male Contraceptive Pill.

Posted by S. Fenella Das Gupta, Ph.D., Neuroscience on with 0 Comments

By S. Fenella Das Gupta,  PhD Neuroscience

A team of researchers led by Dr. Lee Smith at the University of Edinburgh have identified a gene, Katnal1, involved in male infertility.

The expression of this gene is required for the release of mature sperm. So, when it’s disrupted only immature sperm are released.

This finding has great potential for future treatment of male fertility and the development of a non-hormonal male contraceptive.

It's likely that drugs aimed at stopping Katnal1 gene expression will form the basis of this pill, as the testes would continue making sperm, but only ineffective, immature sperm would be released.

Overall, Dr Smith remarks that drugs based on this kind of contraception wouldn’t have any long-term effects on a man’s sperm-making ability. And, the effects of such a drug would be reversible, just like the female contraceptive pill.

Great! Where do I sign up? Oh wait! I can’t sign up- it’s for males. And here’s where it all gets very interesting.

 In a poll conducted at the end of May 2012 in Huff Post UK, Women’s section, asking the question “Would you trust a man to take the contraceptive pill?” From the 100 plus comments on this article, it seems that men and women are at odds over the issue.

51.38 % of female voters responded that they wouldn’t trust a man to take the contraceptive pill.

Of the male voices, many stated that they would be just as reliable as women in taking a daily contraceptive pill. The sentiment expressed was that it would also be in their best interest. After all, “How do you know that the woman really did take her pills that month?” This comment, of course, reflects how women would feel about men around this issue, too.

Arguably as one reader commented, this option would be great for couples with responsible men doing well with it and irresponsible men not- just like women. So perhaps regardless of sex, some will struggle and some won’t.

In an even larger context, could a successful male contraceptive pill affect the economy?  Some suggest that the cost of welfare, food stamps and other stop-gap programs would drop, as there would be fewer single moms out there and more money to spend.  In short, would a male contraceptive pill actually stimulate the economy? It’s interesting to think about.

The social and financial implications of creating such a pill would be phenomenal, assuming of course, that we live in a perfect world where STDs didn’t exist, right?

What are your thoughts?

Fenella Das Gupta is a licensed Marriage and Family Therapist ( #47275) working in Northern California,specializing in fertility counseling. She works with individuals and couples as they make their way through the fertility maze. The other part of her work includes making fertility issues a newsworthy item, as she writes for the Petaluma Patch-a subsidiary of the Huffington Post. To read more about fertility issues in the news go to http://petaluma.patch.com/users/fenella-das-gupta-phd-neuroscience-mft/blog_posts

Comments

to leave comment