Adoption - Ask the Expert
May 29, 2007 - Tuesday
7:31 PM to (EST)
Guest Speakers: Sam Pitkowsky
Adoptive Parents Committee
Categories
Adoption •
International Adoption
| Susan joined. | |
| Corey_Whelan joined. | |
| samapc joined. | |
| Corey_Whelan | Welcome to tonight's chat, on Adoption. I am Corey Whelan, The AFA's Director of Development and your chat moderator. Tonight's special guest is Sam Pitkowsky. Sam is the President of the NY Chapter of the Adoptive Parents Committee, and a nationally known authority on adoption. He truly is a walking encyclopedia on every issue, both international and national. And he's here! Welcome Sam, as well as our early bird, Susan. |
| Corey_Whelan | The chat will officially begin in a few minutes but Susan, please feel free to ask any questions that you may have. |
| Dolores joined. | |
| Dolores | Hi, I have a question - I am single and live in CT. How hard will it be for me to adopt? I haven't started the process yet |
| Corey_Whelan left. | |
| Corey_Whelan joined. | |
| Corey_Whelan | Hi, let's give Sam a few minutes, he may be experiencing some technical issues. |
| Suzi joined. | |
| shazza16 joined. | |
| carolynb joined. | |
| Caitlin joined. | |
| Corey_Whelan left. | |
| Corey_Whelan joined. | |
| samapc left. | |
| Corey_Whelan | welcome all to tonight's chat. I see that Sam is having some technical problems but please feel free to start posting your questions - Carolyn Berger, The AFA's Adoption Coordinator is here and she may be able to assist you while we wait. Welcom Carolyn. |
| carolynb | Thanks, Corey. I'm glad to answer all your questions. There are no stupid questions! |
| makin joined. | |
| hoping joined. | |
| Corey_Whelan | Welcome all. Sam is having some computer glitches, I just spoke to him. Please feel free to post your questions on adoption in the meantime to Carolyn, we are here to help!!!! |
| samapc joined. | |
| bheit joined. | |
| carolynb | I'm an adoptive parent (independent, USA) and run adoption workshops for The AFA. |
| carolynb | Sam Pitkowsky has also adopted, and I have never asked an adoption question he has not given an anwer to! |
| shazza16 | Well, I guess I will start. I am here tonight because my husband and I are considering adoption instead of egg donation. My first question is: where do you start? |
| samapc | Does this work the color is not yellow |
| carolynb | it works |
| Corey_Whelan | YOu're in Sam! Welcome! |
| luna joined. | |
| samapc | The best place to start is together by talking about WHAT YOU WANT// |
| shazza16 | We want a child |
| hope062006 joined. | |
| samapc | The dream is about being amom and dad |
| shazza16 | yes |
| Corey_Whelan | Shazza, what state do you live in? And are your husband and you on the same page about wanting to adopt? |
| samapc | You have to decide what type you now have choices |
| shazza16 | I live in NJ. Absolutely on the same page... |
| JasieJoy joined. | |
| bheit | My wife and I will be embarking upon donor egg in the next several weeks. We would like to be prepared in case this does not work with a back up plan... adoption. We too want a child... we've been through so much but don't really know where to start to find an agency. |
| Corey_Whelan | ok, that's great. Have you thought about domestic vrs. international? Infant vrs. a little older or a lot older? Those are fundamental beginnings. |
| samapc | Both independent adoption and international adoption are open to you |
| hope062006 | Hi My husband I are planning to adopt internationally we live in NY |
| shazza16 | I fear international adoption..... |
| Corey_Whelan | because? |
| samapc | Fundementally talk together about three important issues 1) |
| samapc | age of child |
| shazza16 | Because of the red tape, time taken off from work, traveling expenses....we have already spent a fortune with our own failed IVF's, etc. |
| samapc | ethnicity |
| carolynb | shazza, have you considered domestic adoption then? |
| shazza16 | and I heard the laws in NJ give one year to the bio parents to take that child away. |
| shazza16 | We are considering domestic adoption. |
| luna | shazza I am in NJ and I know how you feel |
| chrissy joined. | |
| samapc | and most importantly how important it is to you to have ahistory of the childs birthfamily |
| samapc | That is not the law |
| Corey_Whelan | Sam, can you address the issue about NJ State law and then can we move back to bheit's question please. And then Hope 062etc. |
| samapc | The law that presides is the law in which the child is born in |
| Corey_Whelan | State of birth of the child |
| samapc | In ny as an example the birthmother has 45days to change her mind in Texas 24hours |
| carolynb | how long does she have in NJ |
| shazza16 | I heard that about Texas, my boss adopted a child from Texas for that reason alone |
| samapc | In new jersy thebirthmother can end their parental rights in court after 30days |
| shazza16 | Great |
| luna | How do you find a trusted agency in NJ for domestic adoption of a newborn? |
| makin | What about Georgia, what are the biological rights timeline |
| samapc | If she does not want to go it increases to 90 days but that is a decresing anxiety that is only overturned by fraud or coercion |
| hoping | how important is it for our child to be introduced to their culture? We are adopting from China. |
| Corey_Whelan | Luna, the AFA has a helpline that can give you referrals for agencies, please feel free to call our 800 number at anytime.The number is 888-917-3777. |
| shazza16 left. | |
| samapc | The best way to find andomestic agency or independent attorney is by being part of a supprt group |
| carolynb | One of the best ways to learn about agencies is by going to Conferences featuring adoption agencies. Also, talking to other parents who have already used a particular agency is invaluable |
| shazza16 joined. | |
| samapc | If you have specific questions concerning an agency even the better bussiness bureau |
| samapc | China question |
| JasieJoy | When adopting internationally, is the health of the child a big issue? Like what are the chances they will have a serious disease etc... |
| carolynb | hoping, most of us in adoption feel it is very important to teach a child adopted internationally about his culture--when you adopt internationally, you are adopting another culture along with your child. |
| luna | Any idea why there is such a wide range in what agencies charge for home studies? |
| samapc | Heritage of a child is VERY important It is their heritage and they have aright to it |
| samapc | Remember to keep it simple do not overemphasize differences |
| bheit | Sam- Not sure if you addressed my question, but what is the general waiting time for domestic Vs. international adoption? What are the general costs? We've done 3 IVF cycles and are getting ready for a donor egg cycle. Just want to know what to expect financially in case this is not successful and we need to move to adoption. |
| hoping | and important for them to know others of their culture? |
| samapc | You always make yourself available to tell the story of the adoption from day1 |
| carolynb | jasie joy: you can learn a great deal about a child's health before going to pick up your baby from another country. You will want to get in touch with an adoption pediatrician. This is a new sub-specialty in medicine. |
| JasieJoy | Would they be here or in the country you are working with? |
| kconnaghan joined. | |
| samapc | Always the problem in achat is too many different questions to fast for my typing |
| samapc | You want apeditrician here to talk to you |
| carolynb | Hoping, there are support groups for parents adopting from different cultures, ie Families With Children From China, Latin American Parents Association, Families for Russian and Ukranian Adoption |
| samapc | To evaluate the health of the child before |
| luna | How do you get support or deal with family members who are not pro-adoption? |
| samapc | and to help afterwords in EARLY (FREE) INTERVENTION for the child |
| hoping | are they able to give you a pretty good idea of the health of the child? Do you have them look at the reports before you say yes to your referral? |
| carolynb | jasie joy: no they are here in the US. |
| makin left. | |
| fortynk joined. | |
| samapc | It all depends on the country and the info you get |
| samapc | Russia has an example |
| carolynb | Hoping, they can look at the reports and pictures of the child. You can call them in the US from your orphanage abroad. |
| JasieJoy | What if they don't know of a condition or health issue |
| samapc | You have to make two trips |
| samapc | One where you gather as much info about the child as possible and than confer with your doctor from russia |
| bheit | what is the general waiting time for domestic Vs. international adoption? What are the general costs? |
| chrissy | We adopted a baby girl, domestic in our state 10 months ago, just curious what the adoptive parents committee is - thanks |
| samapc | again tree questions |
| hoping | congrats chrissy |
| samapc | APC website adoptiveparents.org |
| chrissy | thanks hoping! |
| chrissy | thanks |
| chrissy left. | |
| chrissy joined. | |
| samapc | We give support before , during and most importantly after the adoption |
| samapc | International vs domestic |
| luna | bheit from what I've researched adoption cost can range from 15-40k |
| carolynb | jasie joy: an international adoption pediatrician who has spoken often at AFA Conferences is Dr. Jane Aronson. You can check her website: www.orphandoctor.com |
| chrissy | do you have much support for open adoptions? |
| samapc | The main difference is that in international the waiting times and costs are more defined |
| evaeric joined. | |
| samapc | Domestically and adoption can happan very quickly if the right call comes in quickly |
| chrissy | thats true sam we only waited 4 months from approval |
| samapc | costs vary concerning the birthmothers situation |
| Corey_Whelan left. | |
| Corey_Whelan joined. | |
| samapc | living at home , health insurace, |
| JasieJoy | Do you recommed any particular country for adopting internationally? I've heard it's nearly impossible from Ecuador but easier in others. |
| Corey_Whelan left. | |
| samapc | Equador is impossible |
| samapc | International costs are more defined |
| bheit | Why is that? |
| carolynb | jasie joy: at this moment, people are looking at Vietnam, South Korea, and Ethiopia. Adoptions have run into problems lately in Russia, China, and Guatemala |
| samapc | agency fee, paperwork costs |
| shazza16 left. | |
| samapc | travel expenses are al defined |
| Corey_Whelan joined. | |
| bheit | It was stated before that adoption costs range from 15 to 40K. Is that domestic or international or it just depends on the situation? |
| carolynb | As I learned from Sam, one of the best places to learn about which countries are good for adoptive parents is the US State Department website. |
| samapc | Russia is open an available there are however NO accredited agencies at this time but hopefully changing |
| fortynk | I came in late should i start with a home study or find a lawyer |
| samapc | Independent adoptions with the help of angency is happening in russia |
| luna | Chrissy if you would, could you share what your approximate costs were for your domestic adoption of your baby girl? |
| Chilipep joined. | |
| samapc | china is still open but with strict family rqirements of age, marriage even wieght |
| samapc | Guatamala is basically closed to NEW families right now |
| samapc | Before you answer |
| JasieJoy | What is NEW family defined as? |
| samapc | Costs vary to each situation domesically |
| samapc | Advertising costs, networking costs , where birthfamily lives |
| carolynb | Jasie Joy: A NEW family is a family that is just beginning the adoption process, as opposed to a family that has already taken the steps involved in adopting internationally with the help of an agency or lawyer |
| chrissy left. | |
| samapc | is there medical coverage for the birthmother |
| samapc | and again what state she lives in really affects the costs domestically |
| JasieJoy | so if it's our first international adoption they won't accept us? |
| kconnaghan left. | |
| samapc | Only in certain situations where medicaid can be used |
| fortynk | where to start with a home study or a laywer |
| samapc | Neithe place is your first step |
| Chilipep left. | |
| carolynb | jasie joy: that is true for Guatemala |
| samapc | Gather as much info as you can about the type of child you are looking for |
| fortynk | then can you tell me the first step |
| samapc | In Guatamala to explain |
| samapc | The state dept of the Us believes at this time that there are agreat deal of problems |
| samapc | They are only going to approve families who have already complted most of the paperwork now |
| samapc | they are going to examine every case very carefully |
| fortynk | for international |
| hope062006 | are there countries that we should be aware of that have greater chance of health problems or dangerous to visit |
| shaymer01 joined. | |
| samapc | and only approve squeaky clean adoptions until the process is fixed in Guat |
| Susan left. | |
| JasieJoy | so they will be fixed? |
| samapc | The first steps is to decide that you definitly want and are ready to adopt |
| fortynk | i really need guidence anyone knows of good web sites to help |
| samapc | Than decide what type of adoption you want to pursue based on YOUR fellings |
| fortynk | i am past that i am more than ready |
| samapc | What type of adoption?????? |
| hoping | Do you know if the USCIS is going to extend the time to 18 months that our I171H is good for? |
| kgrothe joined. | |
| samapc | No they have no plans to extend |
| hoping | there is a big letter writing campaign on behalf of some agencies becuase some wait times are very long right now, didn't know if it was helping. |
| fortynk | domestic adoption |
| samapc | We hope that early next year a new process will be put into place in Guat |
| JasieJoy | ok thanks |
| samapc | Domestic adoption is certainly agood choce |
| kgrothe left. | |
| carolynb | fortynk, if you are looking at international adoption, check the US State Dept. website, JCICS websitie, Families for Russian Ukranian Adoption Website, Families with Children From China website, Latin American Parents Association website. Also, a great book for all to read about different types of adoption is A Love Like No Other, Edited by Kruger and Smolowe |
| samapc | Your first step is to begin to tell everyone that yoyu are looking to adopt |
| fortynk | going through that right now |
| samapc | There are approx only 6 attornies in NY strictly doing independent adoption |
| evaeric | When considering open domestic adoption what are pros and cons of working with a lawyer or agency |
| luna | How do you deal with or find support for dealing with family members who are not pro-adoption? |
| pcoleman joined. | |
| hope062006 left. | |
| samapc | take ever opportunity to talk to people about their attornies look for recomendations and interview them |
| hoping | Luna, just to give you courage, it may take time, i wish you the best! |
| samapc | they are your gateway to the process |
| pcoleman left. | |
| Corey_Whelan | folks, we only have five minutes left tonight. |
| JasieJoy | are there countries that we should be aware of that have greater chance of health problems or dangerous to visit |
| samapc | Every family who works hard on their adoption will be come a family |
| samapc | The state dept puts out constant updates and warninmgs |
| JasieJoy | thanks |
| fortynk | thank you |
| carolynb | jasie joy: you can check adoption pediatricians' websites--there is no perfect country health-wise, but most health problems can be resolved when you bring your child into the US |
| samapc | JCICS.org has the most up to date info on counry problems |
| samapc | Always remember be smart lead with head not your heart |
| samapc | Adoption is a great way to become a family but it is a lifetime commitment |
| bheit left. | |
| samapc | Even more than a marriage so be ABSOLUTELY sure |
| hoping | thanks |
| keithnerin joined. | |
| JasieJoy | thanks again for all the answers tonight |
| samapc | To fulfill your dream with the child you really andtruly want not just whtas available |
| Corey_Whelan | Sam and Carolyn, I want to thank you both so much for being here and answering everyone's questions tonight. |
| carolynb | if you persevere, you will adopt--it's as simple as that! |
| Corey_Whelan | And thanks also to all of you for posting your questions and helping to educate us all! |
| samapc | 212 304 8479, samapc@aol.com, adoptiveparents.org |
| carolynb | it has been a pleasure! |
| Corey_Whelan | Good night all. Our chat is officially over |
| hoping left. | |
| Corey_Whelan left. | |
| luna | Thank you |
| evaeric left. | |
| shaymer01 left. | |
| samapc | Good Luck |
| hoping joined. | |
| carolynb left. | |
| keithnerin left. | |
| chrissy427 joined. | |
| samapc left. | |
| hoping left. | |
| Caitlin left. | |
| Suzi left. | |
| Dolores left. | |
| luna left. | |
| chrissy427 left. | |
| JasieJoy left. | |
| fortynk left. |
Categories
Chat Archives
- February 2008
- January 2008
- December 2007
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
- January 2007
- December 2006
- November 2006
- October 2006
- September 2006
- August 2006
- July 2006
- June 2006
- May 2006
- April 2006
- March 2006
- February 2006
- January 2006


